Aplos vs ChurchBooks3: Which Is Better for Small Churches?

Aplos vs ChurchBooks3 for small churches: pricing, fund accounting, ease of use, and setup compared, so a volunteer treasurer can choose the right fit.

Short answer: Aplos is a cloud-based fund accounting system aimed at nonprofits and churches of many sizes. ChurchBooks3 is church accounting software built for small churches run by volunteer treasurers, with a Windows Desktop version and a browser-based Online version. If your church wants the simplest path to clean books, contribution statements, and board reports, ChurchBooks3 is usually the easier fit. If you need a broad nonprofit platform and have someone comfortable with accounting, Aplos is worth a look.

Aplos vs ChurchBooks3 at a Glance

QuestionAplosChurchBooks3
Built forNonprofits and churches of many sizesSmall and mid-sized churches with volunteer or part-time treasurers
Where it runsCloud (web browser)Online (any browser) or Desktop (Windows)
Pricing modelMonthly subscription (see aplos.com for current plans)Online $9.99–$39.99/month; Desktop from $99/year or a one-time $399 Lifetime plan
Fund accountingYesYes
Contribution statementsYesYes, including the IRS Publication 1771 goods-or-services statement
Free trialSee aplos.com30 days, no credit card required
Setup helpSelf-guided with vendor supportComplimentary 30-minute training session with every new trial

What Aplos Does Well

Aplos is a mature, fully cloud-based system. It offers true fund accounting, donor and contribution tracking, and nonprofit reporting, and it serves a wide range of organizations beyond churches. Churches with a trained bookkeeper, several staff users, or more complex grant and nonprofit reporting needs often find it a good match.

What ChurchBooks3 Does Well

ChurchBooks3 is designed for the person who actually keeps the books in most small churches: a volunteer treasurer without formal accounting training. It uses plain church language (tithes, offerings, designated funds, contribution statements) and focuses on the jobs a small church does every week and every year.

  • Record tithes, offerings, and designated gifts, and print year-end contribution statements
  • Keep restricted funds such as building, missions, and benevolence separate from the general fund
  • Produce balance sheets, income and expense reports, and budget comparisons for the board
  • Manage member and family records and attendance alongside the finances
  • Choose Desktop or Online, whichever fits how your church works

Pricing: What Small Churches Actually Pay

Aplos is sold as a monthly subscription. Check aplos.com for its current plans, and compare the plan that includes the accounting features you need, not just the entry price.

ChurchBooks3 Online has four plans from $9.99 to $39.99 per month, billed monthly or annually for the price of ten monthly payments. Full ledger accounting and budgets start with the Silver plan at $19.99 per month. ChurchBooks3 Desktop offers fixed-term service plans from $99 per year, or a one-time $399 Lifetime plan. See ChurchBooks3 plans and pricing for the details.

Ease of Use for Volunteer Treasurers

Both products use fund accounting, so both expect you to think in funds. The difference is how much accounting background each one assumes. ChurchBooks3 keeps the screens and reports focused on church tasks, and a service manager walks every new trial church through setup. That matters when the treasurer changes every few years and the next volunteer has to pick up the books quickly.

Desktop or Cloud?

Aplos runs only in the cloud. ChurchBooks3 gives you a choice: Online for multiple users and access from any device, or Desktop for a church office that wants its data on its own Windows computer. Not sure which you need? Read Desktop vs Online compared.

Which Should Your Church Choose?

Aplos may fit better if:

  • You have a trained bookkeeper or accountant doing the work
  • You need a broad nonprofit platform beyond church accounting
  • You want a cloud-only system and a monthly subscription suits your budget

ChurchBooks3 may fit better if:

  • A volunteer or part-time treasurer keeps the books
  • You want simple church accounting software with contribution statements and board reports ready to use
  • You want a low monthly price, or a Desktop option with a one-time Lifetime plan
  • You would like personal help with setup and training

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Aplos good church accounting software? Yes. Aplos is a capable fund accounting system used by many churches and nonprofits. It tends to suit churches with a trained bookkeeper or more complex nonprofit reporting, while ChurchBooks3 is aimed at small churches with volunteer treasurers.

Is ChurchBooks3 cheaper than Aplos? For most small churches, yes. ChurchBooks3 Online starts at $9.99 per month and Desktop starts at $99 per year, with a one-time $399 Lifetime option. Compare against Aplos's current plans on aplos.com for the features your church needs.

Do both Aplos and ChurchBooks3 handle fund accounting? Yes. Both track restricted and unrestricted funds separately, such as a general fund, building fund, and missions fund, and report each fund's balance.

Can I try ChurchBooks3 before switching from Aplos? Yes. ChurchBooks3 has a free 30-day trial with no credit card required, and a service manager provides a complimentary 30-minute training session to help you set up.

Does ChurchBooks3 have a desktop version? Yes. ChurchBooks3 Desktop runs on Windows for churches that want their data on their own computer. ChurchBooks3 Online runs in any web browser for churches that want remote access and multiple users.

Try ChurchBooks3 Free

Related Resources